Photos

Shy's Original Steakhouse

If you're looking for a place to enjoy a hearty steak in Buffalo, NY, Shy's Original Steakhouse is the destination you don’t want to miss. Located at 690 Fillmore Ave, Buffalo, NY 14212, this restaurant has earned a reputation for offering top-quality steaks and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that draws in both locals and visitors alike. Whether you're a steak aficionado or just looking for a great meal with friends and family, Shy's Original Steakhouse promises an unforgettable dining experience.

A Rich Legacy of Quality at Shy's Original Steakhouse

Shy's Original Steakhouse isn't just another steakhouse in Buffalo. It's a beloved institution that has been serving high-quality cuts of beef to patrons for years. The restaurant has built its reputation on providing exceptional service, generous portions, and, of course, perfectly cooked steaks that keep guests coming back. Whether you prefer your steak rare or well-done, Shy's Original Steakhouse ensures every dish is cooked to perfection.

The restaurant takes pride in using only the best ingredients, and their dedication to quality shines through in every bite. From their juicy, tender ribeyes to their sizzling New York strips, every steak served at Shy's Original Steakhouse is a testament to the culinary expertise that the restaurant is known for. The seasoned chefs here don't just cook steaks; they elevate the dining experience with their attention to detail, ensuring that every meal is memorable.

A Cozy and Inviting Atmosphere at Shy's Original Steakhouse

What sets Shy's Original Steakhouse apart isn’t just the food; it's the inviting atmosphere that makes it the perfect spot for any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a special event, enjoying a casual dinner with friends, or dining solo, you’ll feel right at home. The warm lighting, rustic décor, and friendly staff create an ambiance that’s both comfortable and sophisticated.

Unlike some larger chain restaurants, Shy's Original Steakhouse maintains an intimate charm that makes you feel like part of the family. The restaurant is designed to foster a relaxing dining experience where guests can savor their meal without the hustle and bustle of a crowded dining room. With spacious seating and a cozy, intimate environment, Shy's Original Steakhouse is the kind of place where you can enjoy your meal at your own pace.

Experience the Best Steaks and More at Shy's Original Steakhouse

Of course, the highlight of Shy's Original Steakhouse is the food, and the menu offers much more than just mouth-watering steaks. From fresh seafood to delectable appetizers, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're in the mood for a perfectly grilled steak, a flavorful seafood dish, or a rich dessert to end your meal, the options at Shy's Original Steakhouse are sure to satisfy every craving.

For those who want to start their meal off right, try their crispy calamari or signature shrimp cocktail. These appetizers are the perfect introduction to the main event. When it comes to the steak selection, you’ll find everything from classic filet mignon to hearty porterhouse steaks, each cooked to order with a touch of mastery that sets Shy's Original Steakhouse apart from other restaurants.

Don't forget to pair your meal with a glass of wine from their carefully curated selection. Whether you prefer a robust red or a light, crisp white, Shy's Original Steakhouse has a wine to complement your steak perfectly.

Why Shy's Original Steakhouse is the Ultimate Choice for Steak Lovers

Shy's Original Steakhouse stands out not only for its quality food but also for its consistency and commitment to excellence. The team at Shy's Original Steakhouse is dedicated to ensuring every guest has an exceptional dining experience. Whether it's the personalized service or the perfect preparation of your meal, the restaurant goes the extra mile to create a memorable experience for every diner.

Moreover, the location in Buffalo, NY, makes it an ideal destination for those living in the area or visiting for business or pleasure. It’s conveniently situated and easily accessible, making it a great choice for anyone looking for a standout meal in the heart of Buffalo. The combination of great food, a welcoming atmosphere, and top-tier service makes Shy's Original Steakhouse an exceptional choice for your next dining outing.

The Warm Welcome You’ll Receive at Shy's Original Steakhouse

One of the defining features of Shy's Original Steakhouse is its exceptional customer service. From the moment you step through the door, you are greeted by friendly staff who genuinely care about making your visit special. The service here is more than just efficient; it’s personal. Whether you’re a regular customer or visiting for the first time, you’ll feel like part of the Shy's Original Steakhouse family.

The staff is well-versed in the menu, happy to offer recommendations, and always attentive to your needs throughout your meal. This level of service ensures that your dining experience goes beyond just good food—it becomes a true experience, one that’s marked by hospitality, warmth, and care.

Reviews

Michael W.
Restaurantji Rating

Just arrived in Buffalo and I had an hour to kill and I was hungry so I fired up Yelp and Shy's Original Steakhouse popped up. Boy was I glad it did. First things first--Shy's is a hole-in-the-wall, almost literally. You walk in and there are no tables; just a seated waiting area. You order from a small counter and then wait, but man, is it worth it. I was handed a white bag with a tightly wrapped steak hoagie nestled inside. If you want a drink to go with, you get it yourself out of a vending machine. The steak hoagie was fabulous. Shy's style is more minced than chopped, so the peppers, mushrooms and onions are fully incorporated into the meaty, cheesy mass on the roll. The roll itself was fresh and slightly toasted--just perfect. For a hungry person, this totally hit the spot. If I had been hungover, it would have been heaven and I'd be napping right now. NOTE: Shy's only takes cash but there is an ATM on premises. Six minute ride from downtown Buffalo, and we'll worth it!

Bubbles C.
Restaurantji Rating

This food is so good it makes me wanna buy out there whole supplies and one of there chefs. there food is a work of goodness and one of there chefs David I believe his name was. needs a raise because omg he Was amazing at cooking my steak sub! and the wait was not long. i don't live in buffalo any more but this food made me wanna buy a whole house and stay down there for longer. if u are in buffalo don't walk. run down to shys original steakhouse and get some of that good steak sub!!

Amir P.
Restaurantji Rating

This steakhouse has never failed me. it has the best steak subs around Buffalo. And don't get me started on the customer service it's outstanding The food has my mouth watering if ur in Buffalo u have to try it

Stephanie K.
Restaurantji Rating

We go here every year all the way from Atlanta. The subs are top notch. Highly recommend.

Mike S.
Restaurantji Rating

Steak hoagie was on-point. Reminds me quite a bit of the former Original Steakhouse (on E Delevan) - right down to the smell, taste, and foil wrap presentation. Highly recommended!

Location & Contact

690 Fillmore Ave Buffalo, NY 14212

Opening times

Monday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Sunday Closed
You Can Go To